the Johnny Depp track

This is something of an ongoing conversation from Searching for Stardom but with a slightly different twist.

But the end of the Twilight franchise and Robert Pattison’s successive film choices have prompted considerable discussion on the career paths of young actors. So of course I’ve named them.

Johnny Depp People

The Johnny Depp Track – after bursting onto the pop culture spectrum insisting on taking artsy, independent, quirky, odd and/or challenging roles.

The Julia Roberts Road – also bursting onto the pop culture spectrum but instead of running from it, working consistently for years headlining mid-budget movies (which, to be honest, don’t really exist anymore) before emerging as a powerhouse.
Most actors don’t take this path, especially in this day and age. But it’s worth noting since I mentioned it in my previous post and it is an option (theoretically).

The Brad Pitt Method – getting the attention of the industry, though not necessarily the public right away, and trading off quirky, independent or challenging roles with more commercial projects. The key to the Brad Pitt Method is not running from roles that utilize your looks and charm.

There’s obviously a hundred different ways into an acting career and Movie Stardom. But the consistent thread to come out of my recent conversations is that a lot of actors these days are taking The Johnny Depp Track. They’ve obviously done something worth getting our attention because we know their name enough to include them in this conversation. But they insist on doing character, art house, indie sort of projects. Everyone wants to be like Johnny Depp.

Except you have to acknowledge two flaws in that plan. The first is that Johnny Depp is in a class by himself; he’s a character actor trapped behind a handsome face. And the other is that it wasn’t really a plan even for Johnnny Depp. If he hadn’t done Pirates he’d still be really cool and really respected and not a big star.

Brad Pitt, on the other hand, alternated interesting roles with heart throb roles and has been relied upon by studios to bring in audiences as consistently as Julia Roberts. The advantage he’s had, in balancing more commercial films (and almost always in the shadow of an imminently talented and more respected actor), is the influence and power of a Movie Star (and the money that goes with it).

I’m not saying young actors shouldn’t be good actors, or that challenging, interesting work isn’t better than empty studio fare. I am saying you can’t really build a career on the Johnny Depp track.

But, man, do they ever try.

Robert Pattinson Vanity Fair December 2009 04

Robert Pattinson – Twilight was definitely his 21 Jump Street. Or his Thelma and Louise. He may have enough money that he doesn’t have to care about ever becoming a respected actor or more of a Movie Star than just a celebrity. The potential is there. But he can’t sustain his career just doing the weird, indie movies.

Ryan Gosling New York Times credit Gareth Mcconnell 2007

Ryan Gosling – of all the young actors today he probably is the same sort of guy as Johnny Depp where he isn’t on the Track in order to become a Movie Star. He just cares about doing the projects he wants to do and it doesn’t matter if they bring him fame or fortune. I can respect that.

Chris Hemsworth 2011

Chris Hemsworth – is actually not afraid of the Brad Pitt Method. He’s played the straight up hero and embraced the more commercial films most of his peers shun. He’ll be interesting to watch as he counterbalances that with darker characters that showcase other aspects of his talent. That’s when we’ll see if he falls off the Orlando Bloom Precipice.

Jake Gyllenhaal

Jake Gyllenhaal – I think is actually trying the Brad Pitt Method but his commercial films flop as splendidly as a Johnny Depp film.

Another characteristic of The Johnny Depp Track is refusing to play the straight up hero, employing their good looks and charm, when doing so would make them a Movie Star. Now, to be fair, Brad Pitt never played the stalwart hero. But he’s done his fair share of tortured heart throb roles. And I’m going to have to do an entirely different post on the difference between actors and actresses and how they use their looks or play against them and the dynamics of that. Because there’s just far too much to say.

And the presumption of this post is that actors are using the Johnny Depp Track in order to become Movie Stars. Who knows. They could actually just want to be working actors and doing roles that matter to them is more important than any of the notoriety or acclaim they might bring.

And in today’s paparazzi obsessed world, maybe they really want to somehow be actors and not Movie Stars; forgoing the power and influence to choose (or even produce) their own projects in order to hold onto their private lives a little bit.

But I’m all out of examples for today. Comment and tell me a guy who refuses to play the straight up hero when his looks and charisma are just begging for it. Or the actor who could be a star if he’d stop insisting on doing only indie films.

November 23, 2012 | Commentary , , | this post contains affiliate links

2 responses to “the Johnny Depp track

  1. kel

    i loved this evaluation. because, you’re right, the johnny depp track was a fluke, the massive exception to just about every rule. but, whether intentionally or not, everyone seems to be trying to emulate it.

    what i always wonder is how much of an actor’s career is based on their past work and their own choices, and how much of it is based on their perceived image. while a comedy actor may want to do a serious dramatic role, the world at large might not be able to swallow that or find it believable, and because the casting world senses that, he won’t get cast in a serious drama. but are there a variety of smaller “indie” films that an actor could start off with to establish his versatility early on in his career so as to hopefully avoid stereotypes?

    i guess it all depends on what an actor wants. maybe most of them are content just getting paid to act and making a living off of it. maybe some don’t want to act unless it’s work and characters they feel are worth portraying. and maybe some them really are just after fame and fortune and will take it in whatever form it comes in.

    • aj

      yes! Emulate is such a great word.

      and yes, a lot of the opportunities actors are given are based on their image which is largely determined by what they’ve done before. They have to fight for roles outside their expectations and a lot of time indie films give them more room to stretch into those other dimensions. That’s part of why the Brad Pitt Method works so well, because he balanced those smaller roles that expanded what people believed he could do with his more commercial/good-looking guy roles. He was able to avoid those stereotypes and still play to his strengths.

      that’s the key – who knows what an individual actor actually wants from their career. It makes the whole conversation theoretical but still interesting 🙂